She can go into people's bodies.
Said the ghost has scratched him.
I yelled at whatever was here, "Leave!"
Something is so physically wrong with her.
The body was chopped up and thrown into the harbor.
This is un-[bleep]- bearable.
So much pain!
It's really bad in here.
My name is Amy Allan.
Something is not right.
I see dead people.
This person might have been a serial killer.
I speak to dead people.
You get those chills.
And they speak to me.
He is darkness. He is evil.
But there's only one way to know if my findings are real.
I think she broke her neck.
I rely on my partner.
I'm Steve di Shiavi.
I'm a retired New York City Homicide detective.
You telling me the truth?
And I know every person, every house has secrets.
I think the devil is down here.
It's my job to reveal them.
Who the hell would do this?
But Steve and I never speak...
we never communicate during an investigation.
...until the very end.
Who's he looking to kill?
We uncover if it's safe for you to stay...
You need to get out of here right now.
Or time to get out.
It was like endless darkness.
Amy and I conduct separate investigations.
I hear what living witnesses have to say
and uncover any secrets buried in the property's past
while Amy talks with the dead.
I'm in historic Winthrop, Massachusetts.
It's about 15 minutes outside of Boston.
Amy and I got called in by a woman named Cynthia.
Now, she was hysterical on the phone.
She says that whatever's in the house
is attacking her 14-year-old son, who has special needs.
She says if we can't help,
she's afraid what's going to happen next.
Before Amy arrives,
I look for anything that could reveal information to her,
like family photographs.
Once I conceal them all,
the location will be ready for tonight's walk.
I don't feel good.
There's some woman there.
She's making me so sick.
The dead know I'm coming long before I do.
And one dead woman from this location
is desperate to have her story told.
Oh, man. That is some pain, man.
She's jumped me, entered my body.
And I'm experiencing her pain,
which is so intense that I'm scared for my safety.
This is not good.
This woman that showed up, she is very sick.
She's obviously inconsolable
and in so much pain.
This is un-[bleep]- bearable.
Cynthia, you sounded really concerned on the phone.
We've had a lot of noises, tapping, banging.
I've seen things, shadows.
But, really, the reason why I've called
is my youngest son, Nathaniel.
He's 14 and is in the autism spectrum.
And I really feel this is affecting him.
Okay. In what way?
Well, he's actually been scratched a few times.
He's frightened.
And he's not quite the same anymore,
since we've moved in here.
He was a fun kid, really outgoing.
Okay.
I called him the mayor.
He would be all bubbly and talk to anyone.
And he's just different.
There's no joy anymore.
I'm so mad to see him afraid.
And I yelled at whatever was here to leave him alone.
"My home, my child.
Leave."
It didn't cut it.
I don't know what to do for him anymore. I really don't.
This girl that jumped me,
she can go into people's bodies very easily.
So, I had to, like, disconnect a little bit
because she was making me so sick.
She inadvertently jumps people.
And she is seeking help.
Unfortunately, her presence
can make people feel very, very depressed...
And suicidal.
So, now, who lives in the house with you?
Well, my husband lives here with myself and Nathaniel.
And I have two older sons that live here, as well.
Okay.
And this was my parents' house, and I grew up here.
Oh, okay.
And I wanted to come back to my home.
Well, did you have any experiences when you were...
Yes.
As soon as my parents bought this house,
we all had experiences.
Did you have any hesitation about buying it, then?
Yeah.
I had a catholic priest come in,
bless the house, and pray for Nathaniel.
And I was confident that that would be sufficient.
Now I do feel guilty.
Okay.
Your parents have both passed away?
Yeah. This is my dad.
He passed away here at home in '95.
He had pancreatic cancer.
Ah, geez.
So, now, he passes. What about mom?
She passed in the nursing home.
When I bought the house, she was very upset.
Okay. Was there a reason for that?
I have no idea.
After it closed, she left me a message
that she didn't want me to have the house.
Yeah, but it's to her daughter.
She made it quite clear.
Okay. Did you get along with your mom?
Um...
she was a very irritable-type person.
She had a really bad temper.
Okay.
Did you ever resolve your mother
being upset with you buying the house?
No, not at all.
There is an old lady.
She watches. She's always like this...
Her thing is that if she showed herself for real,
nobody would be afraid of her.
Because who's going to be afraid of a little old lady?
So, she makes herself tall.
Like, if she stands straight up,
she can put her head through the ceiling.
She has, like, a long, spindly, like, neck
and, like, skeleton legs.
It's a very strange composition of pieces.
She's angry, bitter, resentful, hateful.
And when this lady was alive, she was very distant and cold.
She hates humanity in general.
And, you know, she had to, like, hide that.
Do you know when she's from?
She says that she was alive in the '50s.
Okay.
And she was a housewife.
Why'd you bring me in this room?
Well, Nathaniel won't go in his room -- frightened to death.
So, we had to trade bedrooms.
My husband and I are now sleeping in his room.
That was my bedroom as a child.
The bedroom set that's in there now,
that actually was my parents' bedroom set.
Oh, really? When they passed, I kept it.
Okay. That's interesting.
Now, are things any better for you
that you're in the other room?
No, actually.
I've been having terrible nightmares, you know,
where someone gets injured in a boating accident
or crossing the road and getting hit.
It's just... they're violent accidents.
And I'm not one to dream like that.
Are you taking any medication that may cause weird dreams?
No, nothing at all.
How are you living like this?
It's terrible.
Here I am, an adult, and I sleep with a night-light in there.
I do feel like a child is being chased...
and a woman.
Like, emotionally, they're getting chased here.
What do you mean?
I don't know how to explain it.
Are they being chased in their nightmares, maybe?
Oh, she likes this room.
Mm.
She does things in the bed.
She likes to stand right here, slide down real slow,
and then, like, be on the floor, all the way on the floor.
And then, she'll like -- you know, she'll strangle.
But when she touches her, she takes her life.
What do you mean?
She is going to kill her.
So, Nicholas, I understand that this was Nathaniel's room,
but you're sleeping in here? Yes.
So, let me ask you,
what was the breaking point for him to move out of here?
Well, one night, in the middle of the night,
he came running into our room
and said, "There's a guy in my room" --
a shadow man, shadow figure, however he said it.
And he wouldn't come back in his room.
He said, "I'm not going back in there.
I'm not sleeping in there again."
Got to figure out what's going on here.
This is too much.
Your wife said he was getting physically attacked.
Well, actually, one day, he woke up.
And then he came and says, "Mommy, look at my arm."
And we took a picture, and that's what we saw.
And I said, "What happened?"
He says, "A ghost did it."
He said the ghost had scratched him.
Did you guys question him about that?
Yeah. I mean, my first thing is, like,
"Maybe you scratched yourself when you're sleeping."
He said no, he wasn't. He was pretty adamant.
He says, "I wasn't sleeping."
There's no way he would ever make up anything
or do that and then tell us something else.
The old lady, she likes it in this area.
She wants to freak people out
and make them leave and not come in here.
She is very, very proud of inflicting pain.
What kind of pain?
People get scratched here.
What about yourself? Are you having any experiences?
Well, the first night I came in here, I had a nightmare.
I thought it was real, the most vivid dream I probably ever had.
I was looking up at a plane.
The plane started coming down
and, you know, exploded, right into the ground.
Dreams, like, with screaming people in it and violence.
It's kind of interesting how you and your wife
are having the same type of dreams.
Is it just dreams you're experiencing? No.
One night, I woke up wide awake about 3:00 in the morning.
I looked up, and I saw a shadow.
And it was going back and forth across the top of the door.
Like, you could see it blocking the light.
It was about a minute, at least a minute.
And then I got up, and I started to come over here.
And there was nothing here.
This stuff is confusing to me.
We've prayed.
And the priest across the street,
he came in and blessed the house and prayed for Nathaniel.
What I've done, you know, isn't the answer.
So, to me, this would be like a last resort, even,
you know, you guys here.
I believe, like, pretty basic, like, black and white,
like angels and demons, you know, good and bad.
Right. What do you think this is?
There's something wrong.
There's something else that's going on here
with these doors, this hallway.
I'm thinking right now it's the old lady.
Why is she so weird about how she moves?
Mm. She says... Oh, no, yeah.
That adds to, like, the creepy, creepy factor.
She's a sociopath.
She's chasing them, these two people.
One is the living woman.
And the other one, I think it's a boy.
I was talking to mom and dad,
and mom was telling me
that you're having a tough time in the house.
Oh, yeah.
When I go upstairs, it takes me a while to fall asleep
because I feel like I'm being watched for some reason.
And a couple times, I saw this weird black thing.
It was just, like, an outline.
And what did it do?
It just stands there for like five seconds.
And what happened?
It just completely disappeared.
I got so scared,
I actually switched rooms with my parents.
Okay.
Dad showed me a picture of a scratch on your arm.
Yes.
What happened?
I felt, like, a weird burning.
And I looked, and it was a weird scratch.
Did the cat do it or anything?
No, definitely not because it was perfectly fine.
And then, like five minutes later,
there was a weird scratch.
Would you be afraid to be alone in the house?
Yes, actually.
Okay. What about your old bedroom?
That's the worst.
Old lady does weird [bleep] up here.
What does she do?
She does weird stuff on the floor up in here.
And then, there's someone crying about it,
being afraid about it.
I think it takes her a lot to murder someone.
So, she's focused on
offing a living woman that lives here now.
She's just kind of trying to get that done and over with.
And then, she'll move on to the next person.
She's definitely, like, screwing with the kid now.
You know you're in the northeast
when you trace the history on a property
and it takes you back to the 1600s.
Turns out, the first settlers on my client's property
lived there for a couple hundred years.
I asked a local genealogist to look into it for me,
and he said he found something that will help my case.
You know, Steve, this is one of the oldest deeds
I've ever searched through.
It goes back to the 1600s.
And I came across the Bill and Belcher families.
Mm-hmm.
What can you tell me about them?
In November of 1635,
John Bill and his wife
came from England with their family.
And by 1690, the family owns most of Pullen Poynt,
today's Winthrop. Okay.
So, how does the Belcher family get involved?
Well, in 1697, Hannah Bill marries Joseph Belcher.
Okay. So, these were two pretty prominent families, then.
Exactly.
Now, you said there was some information on the phone
that would help my case. What were you talking about?
Well, I went through over 200 years of records.
And, of course, there's deaths, standard things...
That is until the mid-to late-1800s.
Okay. During that period,
a dozen Belcher children under the age of four die.
Okay. Do you know what they died from?
You might want to take a look at some of these death records.
Most of it was common ailments of the time --
cholera, consumption,
what we know today as tuberculosis.
So, we're talking about some kind of an epidemic?
No.
But in the 1700s, there was an outbreak of smallpox.
And that was in the area I'm investigating?
Exactly.
Okay.
I saw the old lady.
And then I saw these three little kids.
And she was claiming that she killed them.
Then I heard a man say that she didn't kill them.
This is not a good room.
Pain and then pain, pain.
Blood and death and pain.
Now that I know there was a smallpox epidemic in Winthrop,
I need to find out more about it.
I'm heading over to meet with a local historian.
He says there's a direct connection
between the outbreak and the property I'm investigating.
So, Bob, I understand that there was a smallpox epidemic
related to the property I'm investigating.
Correct.
When did it happen?
December of 1751.
So, how does this epidemic start?
The ship The Bumper came into town
and ran aground here in Winthrop.
Captain Nicholas Cousens,
actually, he had a crew member that was sick.
And he quarantined him on ship prior to this crash.
He ordered everybody off the ship.
And then he just basically got townspeople
to help out him unloading his ship.
So, that's how it winds up spreading?
Correct.
That's a scumbag move. It is.
Over 7,500 people got infected.
569 people died.
Wow.
Considering the time it was and the amount of people,
that's a lot of people.
A lot of people, especially around this area.
I mean, back then, they were mainly farmers.
What do you know about the symptoms of smallpox?
Well, you have a high fever, body ache,
have open sores, and stuff like that.
And if you'll look at this picture,
you can see how painful it can be.
This is what a guy would look like?
That's what it looks like. Oh, geez.
Yeah.
So, Bob, you mentioned on the phone
there was a direct connection
between the epidemic and the property I'm investigating.
Right. Because a lot of the patients
were actually taken to John Bill's house,
the owner of that property.
That took a lot of guts for this guy to do that.
A lot of guts, yep.
I see all of these men running up from over here.
They're all dying.
And they're all scared.
They're all white men.
There is so much pain.
All these dead -- these dead souls, these men.
There's so much sadness here.
I'm at the local library to see what else I can uncover
about my client's property.
Digging through old records,
I find a young woman named Suzanna Geary who died in 1905.
But what's really disturbing is where her body was discovered --
washed up onshore right by Cynthia's house.
I'm heading over to meet with a local police lieutenant
who I asked to look into it for me.
He says this story is every parents' nightmare.
Lieutenant, came across this gruesome case back in 1905.
Body washed up on the shore
pretty close to the property I'm investigating.
What do you know about it?
Suzanna Geary --
20-year-old dancer originally from Massachusetts
working in a performance in Boston.
This is a picture of her right here
taken from a newspaper back in 1905.
She's a pretty girl. Yeah, pretty girl.
She was going out with one of the stage managers of her production company.
Okay.
She became pregnant, wasn't married...
Ah.
...and things started to go bad from there.
I know that this woman is younger,
probably in her teen or 20s.
She has long hair about here, brown.
She'd kind of skinny for a pregnant woman.
The young girl who jumped me at the start of my walk
has left my body.
And I'm now able to see what she looked like in life.
I'm surprised to find that she's pregnant.
Very pretty, large, brown eyes.
Very dark.
Um...
and obviously very sad.
So, what happens next?
Suzanna and her boyfriend, Nathan --
here's a sketch of him right here...
...they decide that having this baby
isn't going to be the best for either of them in their careers.
And they decide to go have an illegal abortion.
They find a doctor in the Boston area.
Okay. That doesn't go so well
because she develop septicemia and peritonitis,
two highly infectious diseases.
They're serious today, never mind back then.
I've heard of it. But what are the symptoms?
You have any idea? Well, I know that a sepsis infection
is in your bloodstream,
and it can travel throughout your body.
Causes excruciating pain. It's a deadly disease.
Okay. So, now, she develop this infection.
And I assume she goes back to the doctor?
That is correct.
A second procedure is performed
by this doctor, Percy McLeod.
But they go back to the same office?
Yes. But this is a new doctor that sees her?
We don't know exactly who performed the first procedure.
It could have been Dr. McLeod.
He was trying to fix whatever went wrong with the first procedure.
And instead of fixing it, she dies a day later.
She was pregnant...
and she lost the baby.
And I think she lost her man.
Something is so physically wrong with her.
This woman's physical and emotional trauma is so severe
that I'm experiencing all of the pain she felt
when she was alive.
I've never felt so much pain.
It hurt.
It was so painful.
Seriously, I would've [bleep] just shot myself in the head.
Her loss is just...
Oh, it's really bad.
So, how do we end up with her going DOA in a doctor's office
to being in the water?
I'm sure that the doctors,
realizing that they had a dead body on their hands,
panicked and started to try to cover up their tracks,
try to dispose of the body
so that no finger-pointing would be made
that they were doing any kind of illegal activity.
These two gentlemen here --
hired by the doctor to dispose of the body.
The body was chopped up, went into suitcases,
and thrown into the harbor.
So, what happens next?
Two young boys in a rowboat saw the bag floating,
decided to bring it in.
God knows what's inside of it.
They bring it to shore, they open it up,
and wrapped up inside was a torso.
What did they do with the torso at this point?
Well, it's right next to the cemetery.
They bring it in to the cemetery.
And that's right next to the house I'm investigating.
Exactly.
Somehow, the mother identifies it as her daughter.
So now we have a victim.
We found an article, actually, of divers
looking for other evidence.
And that's when they discovered her head.
Oh, wow. Look at this.
So, now, what winded up happening with the doctor?
Did he ever get convicted or charged?
The people that helped the doctor, they were convicted.
They were sent to the Charlestown penitentiary
for seven years.
The doctor in this case, he was charged,
but he was acquitted.
During my walk, a traumatized young woman jumped my body.
I'm meeting with a sketch artist
to describe how she appeared in life.
She was on the thin side.
Deep-brown colored eyes, very large.
Very pointy chin.
Yes, that's who I saw.
Now that Amy and I have completed our investigations,
we're ready to reveal our findings to each other
and our clients for the first time.
Amy, I want you to meet Nicholas and Cynthia.
This is their home.
They've both experienced a lot of things here.
But the main reason they called us
and their main concern is their 14-year-old son, Nathaniel.
Okay.
He has special needs,
and it seems like he's being singled out
and victimized in a violent manner.
What they want to know from us
is if it's safe enough to stay here.
With that, I'm going to ask her
to tell us about how her walk went.
On my way to do the walk, I was jumped by a female.
And I became violently ill.
It was extremely sudden, totally unexpected,
and extremely overwhelming.
She felt so much loneliness.
Okay.
Getting jumped is not easy for her.
I hate when it happens.
Hmm.
I can't even imagine living with that kind of pain.
If I had been her,
I would have just taken a gun and shot myself in the head.
The thing is is that she doesn't mean to jump people.
But when she does, the people can become violently ill,
extremely depressed, possibly suicidal.
One of the things you told me about your son
was how his personality changed.
Well, really shortly after we moved in,
he just really changed.
I used to call him the little mayor.
Talked to everyone.
Now, he doesn't want to really go out
and do things with other kids
or enjoy school activities like he used to.
Were you able to find anything else about her?
Well, she's probably between 16 and 22, I would say.
Very little, thin, pale.
She had very long brown hair and huge brown eyes.
And what I figured out was that sense of loss
was because she had been pregnant
and lost her child.
A lot of it's making sense.
It's not a story you're going to want to hear.
So, a young dancer by the name of Suzanna Geary.
She was 20 years old.
She was from Boston.
Her boyfriend, who was the stage manager
for the dancing troupe she was in got her pregnant.
Uh-oh.
And they decided to get an abortion,
which obviously was illegal back then.
And there's a sketch of her boyfriend.
This is Morris Nathan.
Now, while she's recovering,
she develop what they call septicemia.
She got very sick, excruciating pain, apparently.
So, she goes back to Dr. Percy McLeod.
They do another procedure.
Didn't go too well.
She dies the next day.
Now, the police at the time believed he panicked.
He cuts her up...
dismembers her body,
then hires two guys to take the body and get rid of it --
throws it into the harbor.
God.
A few days later,
her body washes up very close to the house.
Now, I've got a picture of her.
And she's a pretty girl, too.
Oh, my God.
Well, I did do a sketch of her.
And this is the same girl that jumped you?
Yes.
You take a look at that.
Without question, that's her.
Wow.
The eyes, the eyes.
Mm-hmm.
That's horrible.
I mean, I can't even put words to that.
What else did you see on your walk?
So, I came into the house,
and in the kitchen, I see this elderly woman.
And she is filled with resentment, hatred, bitterness.
She was very cold and distant in life.
One of the things that she expressed
was that she absolutely disdains humanity
and that when she was alive she had repressed that.
She told me that she lived here, I think, in the '50s,
that she was a housewife.
You mentioned your mom wasn't always that great, that nice.
Yeah, my mother kind of didn't like a lot of people.
She kind of ruled the roost a lot.
She didn't like anybody.
I'm trying to be gracious.
She actually said that she loved the dog better than my children.
Really?
You said you got a good look?
Mm-hmm.
Wow.
Is that who you saw?
Yeah. That looks like her.
But definitely older.
She didn't want you to have the house, either.
No, mnh-mnh.
When she found out the house was sold and the papers passed,
she just was really upset and left me a voicemail.
She said I stole the effing house.
And she doesn't give an "f" what I think.
And "f" me, and "f" everyone else.
And use your imagination.
Well, all I know is
that the woman I met repressed a lot of stuff,
like did not really give a [bleep] about anybody.
Mm-hmm.
Sounds right.
What is she doing around the house?
Nothing good.
She wants to scare people.
She had made herself about seven to eight feet tall.
Like, she was showing me
this monstrous, disgusting, deformed thing.
And that helps her to frighten and cause fear and all of that.
I know she can get physical in the house to people.
Like, upstairs in the master bedroom,
I saw her coming through the wall.
And she'll, like, slink down onto the floor
and then come up the bed
and, like, attempt to strangle
the female that sleeps in the bed.
The other thing that she tries to do is,
she likes to enter nightmares and create them.
And what she'll do is get in there
and literally make the people
feel like they're being chased by her.
Now, you guys are sleeping in there,
and you're having nightmares every frigging night.
Yeah.
I've had nightmares, vivid nightmares.
It's always something violent.
Last night, I had one of a parachute jump go wrong.
There was also boating accidents,
just horrible things like that.
Now, you mentioned that it can get physical.
This is a picture of Nathaniel.
Oh, okay.
And he's been woken up with scratches on him.
Wow.
It's happened a few times.
Another time, I put him to bed,
and he woke up in the morning, and he had a long 8-inch scratch
right from the groin area all the way down.
Is she capable of doing this on Nathaniel like that?
Very possible.
Very.
Because what she's doing now is just inflicting pain,
like, whether it's mentally, emotionally, physically.
And now, she definitely has her sights set
on two individuals in the house.
One was the young boy.
And the other is the lady of the house.
You're the only lady in the house.
Mm-hmm.
Oh, boy.
What I got was that, you know,
she's trying to, like, you know, really strangle you,
like, to death...
...and that she wants to get you and then go after him.
I definitely got the sense
that she would go after him big-time, too.
I feel sick right now.
She's trying to, like, you know,
really strangle you, like, to death.
And she wants to get you and then go after him.
I feel sick right now.
You don't look surprised.
No.
I know the whole family,
and I saw what she did to, basically, all of them.
You okay?
Yeah.
This is probably one of the hardest reveals I've ever done.
Did you feel abused when you were a kid?
Oh, yeah. Absolutely. Oh, absolutely.
I'm just surprised with Nathaniel.
She was always like that.
I mean, does she really feel like
you guys just ruined her life, or what?
Oh, yeah. She had a hot temper, for sure.
Well, I know this isn't what you wanted to hear.
I know it's something I didn't want to hear, either.
The big question left is,
is it safe for you to raise Nathaniel in the house?
For that, I'm going to turn it over to Amy.
What you need to deal with
is getting rid of unwanted visitors, so to speak.
So, therefore, we kind of want to put her to rest
so that you're not going to have to deal with her.
Because my fear is that if you don't take care of her now,
it's going to get worse.
It could be so debilitating,
I don't know if you could get her out.
My suggestion is
to get an individual that is a mental medium.
A mental medium is a type of medium
that does not feel the individual's death.
Therefore, they won't be as impacted by her.
So, what is this mental medium going to do?
I would suggest that they go in your backyard,
talk to her over two days.
What they're basically going to be talking to her about
is letting her tell them her story
to help her to move on.
Will she leave at that point?
Yes.
So, it sounds like the biggest problem here is your mom.
Mm-hmm.
As far as she's concerned,
what I would suggest doing is writing a letter to her.
In this letter, I would like you to focus
on what she is no longer allowed to do,
that she is no longer allowed
to control you, your home, your family, or your dreams,
that you are taking back the power and control
of your home and your family.
And then, have a physical medium,
which is somebody like me, come to the home.
And you and this physical medium are going to deal with her.
Then, you're going to read your letter.
I want you to yell. I do.
I feel like you need to fricking yell at her.
Don't let her stop you.
I don't care whether you feel like you're going to throw up.
I don't care if you do throw up.
I don't care what happens
as long as you finish what you write.
Right. Once you're done,
then you tell that physical medium, "Get rid of her."
Are you afraid to do this?
Uh, anxious.
Once I get started, I'll be on a roll.
I see how protective you are of him.
Yes. I am very much.
What about you? Are you going to take Amy's advice?
Yes, definitely.
I look forward to it.
Cynthia has her work cut out for her.
But I believe if she's able to stand up to her mother,
she'll free her family of the evil that's tormenting them
and they'll be able to live a peaceful life.